A shirtless torso with an arm raised, jeans at the hips
Dark Room No. 1 · History of looking

Size queens of the 1960s

The physique magazines swore it was all about muscle. The posing strap, and the caption with his measurements, said otherwise.

By Dark RoomThe Heat Issue · November 20266 min read

A size queen, in gay slang, is a man who prefers his partners well endowed, and does not mind who knows it. By the 1960s and 1970s gay men had a whole taxonomy of queens: muscle queens, size queens, and dozens more that have since dropped out of use. In 1972 a San Francisco writer named Bruce Rodgers published The Queens' Vernacular, a lavender paperback lexicon of more than 12,000 entries, mostly slang from the 1950s to the early 1970s, gathered by interviewing men in bars, steam baths, dance halls and on street corners. It came out three years after Stonewall, when homosexuality was still illegal in 46 states.

The pouch

Physique magazines ran from the early 1950s to the mid-1960s, and their alibi was health. Bodybuilding, classical art, "studies in masculine form." Full nudity could not go through the mail, so the posing strap, a pouch on a string, was as far as a page could go. Everybody looked at the pouch. The captions helped: many studios printed a model's full measurements under his photograph, chest and arms and waist, and readers did the rest of the math themselves.

Michael Juwa La Vonce, Physique Pictorial Jul 1962At the fence, Grecian Guild Studio Quarterly Summer 1964
Left: Michael Juwa La Vonce, full measurements in the caption, Physique Pictorial, 1962. Right: a pouch at the fence, Grecian Guild Studio Quarterly, 1964.
Fizeek - May 1962 cover, Fizeek May 1962Big grin, Male Classics Oct 1964
Left: Fizeek, May 1962, a white pouch in a black-and-orange frame. Right: a striped pouch, Male Classics, 1964.
American Apollo No. 1 - cover, American Apollo May 1958
American Apollo No. 1, May 1958: "Your health guide." The cover also asks whether you are sexually impotent. See the original.
The alibi was health. Everybody looked at the pouch.

The Post Office vs. the pouch

On March 25, 1960, the postmaster in Alexandria, Virginia, seized six parcels holding 405 copies of three physique magazines from the publisher Herman Womack: MANual, Trim and Grecian Guild Pictorial. The Post Office declared them obscene and unmailable, and an appeals court agreed. Womack took it to the Supreme Court. On June 25, 1962, in MANual Enterprises v. Day, the Court reversed: the magazines were not obscene and could not be kept out of the mail. It was the first case involving the physique trade, or any gay content, to reach the Court, and it is often called the first gay rights victory there.

Trim - May 1957 cover, Trim May 1957Trim - August 1957 cover, Trim Aug 1957
Two covers of Trim, one of the three magazines in the case. May and August 1957.

After the strap

The ruling helped open the door, and within a few years the pouch was on its way out. As the law loosened through the 1960s, the physique genre faded, the newsstand monthlies arrived, and measurements stopped being implied. The queens kept their vocabulary.

Now

Size never left the conversation; it just moved into your bio. This month Grindr bought Freddie, the health brand whose magazine runs a frank explainer on what a size queen is and why it is worth thinking about where our preferences come from. The 1962 Supreme Court would have needed a lie down.