A muscleman in a cropped tee from Jim French's State of Man greeting cards, Blueboy, September 1984
Dark Room · Gift guide

Gay Secret Santa gifts that get passed around the room

You drew his name. You have a budget. Here is how to win the exchange without getting a call from HR.

By Dark Room6 min read

The best gay Secret Santa gift is small, funny and a little bit queer: a vintage pulp poster, a print from an old gay magazine, or a calendar he will actually hang. Sort it by how well you know him, keep it office-safe if it is an office exchange, and save the hotter stuff for the friends' party.

Where did Secret Santa come from?

The anonymous-giver idea is old, but the name got famous through Larry Stewart, a businessman known as Kansas City's Secret Santa. From 1979 through 2006 he handed out cash, often hundred-dollar bills, to strangers who needed it, and kept his identity hidden until 2006. He died in January 2007. Your exchange is lower stakes, but the rule is the same: the gift should feel like someone actually thought about him.

For the coworker you barely know

Go funny, not personal. The panicked anti-gay paperbacks of the 1950s and 60s are now the best joke on any desk, and nobody can be offended by a book cover that offended everyone sixty years ago.

Advertisement · Dr. SickoTwo Beers Will Make You QueerPanic-era pulp, reborn as wall art. Prints from Dr. Sicko.
Shop pulp posters →

For the friend who loves a calendar

Gay calendars are an old tradition. Physique artists sold them by mail in the 1960s, and in 1984 Tom of Finland advertised his own calendar in Blueboy for $8.50 plus postage, from a P.O. box in Los Angeles. A vintage-art calendar or a set of small monthly prints is a stocking stuffer that lasts all year.

Tom of Finland 1984 Calendar ad, Blueboy Sep 1984Etienne calendar - August, Etienne (Dom Orejudos) 1963
Tom of Finland 1984 Calendar ad, Blueboy, September 1984, and the Etienne calendar, August 1963. Shop prints at Dr. Sicko.

For the one who is always planning a trip

Gay group travel has its own history. Hanns Ebensten, who opened his company in New York, ran what his firm calls the first tour for gay men, a Grand Canyon rafting trip in 1973, and later moved the office to Key West. His 1984 ad for a men-only Nile cruise is the kind of print a travel addict hangs by the door. Pair it with a guidebook or a luggage tag and you are done.

Cruise the Nile with us, Blueboy Sep 1984
"Cruise the Nile with us," Hanns Ebensten Travel, Blueboy, September 1984. Shop prints at Dr. Sicko.

For the gym rat

He will pretend not to like it and then hang it over the bench. A sunny 1980s pin-up from a greeting card, or a 1950s physique page, is safe for the living room and does more for his motivation than another shaker bottle.

Would You Date This Man?, Blueboy Sep 1984
From Jim French's "State of Man" greeting cards for Colt Studio, in Blueboy, September 1984. Shop prints at Dr. Sicko.

For the fashion queen

He knows who Bruce Weber is. Give him the 1984 Blueboy page on French underwear ads, photographed by Weber, or a print from a 1970s fashion story. It is art history and a style reference in one frame.

French Underwear, Blueboy Sep 1984Cucumber mask, Blueboy Oct 1978
"French Underwear," photos by Bruce Weber, Blueboy, 1984, and the cucumber mask, Blueboy, October 1978. Shop prints at Dr. Sicko.

For the friends' party, not the office

If the exchange is just the group chat, go hotter. Our Dark Room originals are moody, shadowy and not for the break room.

How to keep it office-safe

Pick humor over skin, covers over centerfolds, and anything you would be happy to see unwrapped in front of your manager. A pulp title with a punchline is safer than a pin-up. Wrap it flat, and add a small frame so he does not have to buy one.

Quick answers

What is a good Secret Santa gift for a gay coworker? Something funny and office-safe, like a vintage pulp cover poster or a small art print. Avoid anything explicit or too personal.

What are good gay stocking stuffers? Small prints, postcards, a vintage-art calendar or a funny pulp poster rolled in a tube.

Who started Secret Santa? Anonymous gift-giving is old, but Larry Stewart, known as Kansas City's Secret Santa, made the name famous by giving cash to strangers from 1979 through 2006.

When should I order for a December exchange? By early December, so prints arrive with time to frame or wrap.

Start here