Mustache men, uncovered
The full mustache was the badge of the late-1970s clone, and the New York glossies put it on every page. These are the uncovered ones.
Long before the clones, the mustache was already in the life room: Edgar Degas drew a mustached model reclining in Rome in the late 1850s, and Georges Seurat drew another leaning on a pole in 1877, both now in the Art Institute of Chicago. Around 1900 the Ecole Desbonnet in Paris photographed mustached pupils for its before-and-after body records.
The look came roaring back in the late 1970s, when men on Castro Street in San Francisco paired flannel, Levi's and boots with a full mustache and the activist Arthur Evans named them clones. The New York monthlies followed: Honcho from its first year in 1978, Mandate and Playguy, and Colt Studio's 1978 books with the mustached model billed as Bruno. Even Mr. International Leather wore one in Honcho's June 1982 issue. The plates here run from Degas to Honcho's 1983 'Pride and Joy' set, each credited to its source.
Quick answers
When did the gay mustache become popular? In the late 1970s, as part of the Castro clone look of flannel, Levi's, boots and a full mustache; the activist Arthur Evans named the clones.
Which magazines ran mustache pin-ups? Honcho from 1978, Mandate and Playguy in New York, and Colt Studio's books, among others.
Are there older mustache nudes in art? Yes. Degas and Seurat both drew mustached academy models in the 1850s and 1870s; those drawings are now in the Art Institute of Chicago.
Sources on this page: Colt Studio Presents, Desbonnet collection - BnF, Ecole Desbonnet - Wellcome (CC BY 4.0), Edgar Degas - Art Institute of Chicago, Georges Seurat - Art Institute of Chicago, Honcho, Mandate, Playguy.