Everard Baths
The Everard Baths was a bathhouse at 28 West 28th Street in Manhattan, opened by James Everard in 1888 in a former church, used by gay men by World War I, damaged in a fire that killed nine men on May 25, 1977, and closed by the city in April 1986.
The Everard Baths at 28 West 28th Street was one of New York's best-known gay bathhouses for most of the 20th century. Wikipedia describes it as the "classiest, safest, and best known of the baths," and the Smithsonian calls it the city's oldest continuously operating gay bathhouse at the time of its closing.
History
The building began as the Free Will Baptist Church in 1860, became the New-York Horticultural Society's Horticultural Hall in 1882 and then a music hall financed by James Everard (1829-1913), a Dublin-born brewer and financier. After the city closed the music hall over beer sales, Everard reopened it in May 1888 as a "Russian, Turkish, Roman & Electric" bathhouse. The NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project says it was a refuge for gay men probably from its opening and definitely by World War I, and by the 1920s it was patronized largely by gay men. On January 5, 1919, a raid encouraged by the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice led to the arrest of the manager and nine customers; a second raid in 1920 led to 15 arrests, but police raids were otherwise rare. Patrons named in histories include Alfred Lunt, Noel Coward, Lorenz Hart, Truman Capote, Gore Vidal, who met his partner Howard Austen there in 1950, Ned Rorem and Rudolf Nureyev.
The 1977 fire
On May 25, 1977, a fire killed nine patrons, aged 17 to 40, and injured about a dozen people, including two firefighters; the Smithsonian reports that some 200 firefighters needed nearly two hours to put it out. The cause was never definitively determined. The city had ordered a sprinkler system in 1964 and again in 1976, but the one installed had not been connected to the water main; the building had no fire escapes and its windows were covered over. The upper floors were destroyed. Drummer 17 (1977) ran "Goodbye to the Everard," a tribute by A. Jay and a report by George Birimisa on the fire and the protests at City Hall that followed.
Closing
The baths were rebuilt with an altered facade and reopened. In April 1986 the city under Mayor Ed Koch closed the Everard as part of its AIDS-era crackdown on bathhouses. The Smithsonian notes that the building later housed a beauty supply store, with little left of the bathhouse beyond the pilasters around the arched doorway.
In the archive
Goodbye to the Everard: the 1977 Everard Baths fire, 1977
"Hollywood Spa", Sep 1974
"Now... Over 300,000 Members", Dec 1977
"We're Number 1, 2 & 3 in New York City", Apr 1978
"Make a Big Splash in the Big Apple", Sep 1979
"If Your Card Doesn't Offer You 1400 Rooms...", Nov-Dec 1979
"The CBC Forecast... Hot All Over", Sep 1979
The Club Baths: "Make a Big Splash in the Big Apple", Mar 1979
Club Honolulu: "Honolulu Hot!!! Now Open", Mar 1979
The hot tub, May 1982
"It's Time for the Club", Sep 1982
"There Is More Than Pineapple in Paradise", Sep 1982Quick answers
Where were the Everard Baths? At 28 West 28th Street in Manhattan, New York City, in a building that began as a church in 1860.
What happened at the Everard Baths fire? On May 25, 1977 a fire killed nine men and destroyed the upper floors. A sprinkler system had been installed but was not connected to the water main.
When did the Everard Baths close? The city closed it in April 1986, during the AIDS crisis, under Mayor Ed Koch.

See also
Sources
- Everard Baths - Wikipedia
- Everard Baths - NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project
- Before It Burned Down, This Bathhouse Served as a Haven for New York City's Gay Community - Smithsonian Magazine
- Everard Baths, New York City: 1888 to 1985 - OutHistory
- Goodbye to the Everard - Drummer 17, 1977 (Internet Archive)
"Everard Baths." The Encyclopedia of Gay Art, Vintage Gay Art, updated 2026-11-21. https://vintagegayart.com/encyclopedia/everard-baths.html